1.Introduction
1.1.What is a POI?
A POI is a Point of Interest, an entity that might be listed in a yellow pages directory and that users would want to navigate to and/or find on a map.
The POI Evaluation task determines the validity of the POI and the accuracy of the Listing

This presentation provides educational content and worked examples pertinent to Denmark and are for use in combination with the POI Evaluation Guidelines

1.2.Research Expectation (POI Evaluation Guidelines, section 1.5. Research Expectation)

The expectations, when rating these tasks, are that analysts:

Use official webpages
Use other official resources, including claimed social media pages (updated within the last 6 months), street imagery, postal authorities
When official resources are not available, user other reliable resources, including newspaper sites or crowdsourced user review sites (Tripadvisor, Trustpilot are examples of this type of site)
Use a search engine to locate official resources
Use local knowledge, when relevant, to understand POI details

HINT: You must always perform online research to verify the POI validity and listing information

.

2.Key Concepts

These concepts are of particular relevance to analysts rating tasks in Denmark

 

2.1Validity
Yes – Confirmed using other resources
No – closed – Confirmed using other

resources

 

2.2Name

Partially Correct – Name includes corporate structure

2.3 Address

Incorrect – Missing sub-locality

2.4Phone
Can’t Verify – No official resource
Missing – Confirmed using other resources
2.5URL
Incorrect – URL reroutes
OK Without – No URL available
2.6Category

Correct – Category appears too general

2.7Pin
Approximate – Single rooftop POIs
Approximate – Single Entity with multiplerooftop POIs

 

2.1Validity (POI Evaluation Guidelines, section 3. POI Validity)

The POI are verified using official resources, such as business’s official website, claimed social media pages, and/ or other official resources in addition to other sources listed in section 3.1.1. Research Expectations of the guidelines.

It must represent an entity in the real world that a user would want to locate on a map and that is currently active.

The validity can be rated as Yes, Yes – temporary closure, No – closed, No – no physical location, No – mobile business, No – service business out of a home, No – not a POI, Cant’ Verify.

HINT: Some POIs are not expected to have official websites or claimed social media pages.

.

.

 
 
 
2.2Name (POI Evaluation Guidelines, section 4. Name)

The POI name is correct when it is used on the POI’s official website or other official resources.

Every name that a specific business uses to refer to itself is considered Correct.

The name data can be rated as Correct, Partially Correct, or Incorrect.

Partially Correct is used when the name contains minor misspellings, alterations to the official name, or is a name that implies a variation in the level of service provided/ kind of business it is. Most importantly, the name can still be recognized by the user, POI Evaluation Guidelines, section 4.1.2. Partially Correct

HINT: Rate Partially Correct for any issues that don’t prevent the user identifying the POI

 

.

2.3POI Address (POI Evaluation Guidelines, Section 5. Address Accuracy)

There are several reasons that a POI address might be incorrect. Here is one of these reasons analysts in Denmark need to be especially aware of:

Incorrect – Missing Sub-locality

The POI result address does not include a sub-locality, but this appears on the official website or claimed social media page and this is a valid address component.

POI Evaluation Guidelines, Section 5.1. Address Rating Options state in such cases address should be marked Incorrect due to missing information.

HINT: Check missing components against https://danmarksadresser.dk , the government resource.

.

2.4Phone (POI Evaluation Guidelines, section 6. Phone)

The phone number should be verified using official resources, such as business’s official website, claimed social media pages, and/ or other official resources.

The phone number data can be rated as Correct, OK Without, Missing, Incorrect or Can’t Verify.

Can’t Verify is used only when a phone number cannot be verified using an official online source, i.e. no phone number is found on any official source. POI Evaluation Guidelines, section 2.1.3 Official Resources

Missing is used when no phone number is returned but one is confirmed using either official resources, or if not available, other reliable resources. POI Evaluation Guidelines, section 2.1.3 Official Resources ‘…are used to confirm any POI details that are not available on an official web page…’

HINT: Formatting is not a reason to demote a phone number to Incorrect

2.5URL 

2.5 URL (POI Evaluation Guidelines, section 7. URL)
In the task, the listed URL is checked to see if it matches the official website address. The URL can be determined to be Correct, Partially Correct, OK Without, Missing, Incorrect or Can’t Verify.
URL Redirects
When research shows that the POI has an official website, and the listed URL navigates to the same official website the URL is deemed correct. However, if the result URL is different to the official website, even if the result URL redirects to this, it cannot be rated Correct. This can happen when a POI has rebranded or been taken over and a new website is created with the new POI name and details.

 

Example 2 URL

OK Without –No URL available

POI Name: Fasanvej/Fuglebakkevej

Address: 8210 Aarhus

URL:

Category:hotelstravel.transport.publictransport.busstops

Pin: 56.166514, 10.179514

No URL is listed in the result data. The result category indicates a bus stop which is confirmed by recent street imagery of the pin location. No website or claimed social media page is found for this bus stop, as anticipated

2.6Category (POI Evaluation Guidelines, section 8. Category)

A POI’s category should best reflect the dominant identity of the POI. When evaluating the POI’s category, t.he considerations are:

Is this category accurate for this POI?
Is this the best fit category available in the category list?

A category can fully describe, generally describe, partially describe, or not describe the POI. A category that does not describe the POI should be rated Incorrect, the other rating options are Approximate – too general, Approximate – too specific and Missing.

HINT: Familiarize yourself with the POI categories and their localizations in the category list

2.6.1 Category -The Category Listegory Rating Rules

The Category list is linked to at the top of each POI Evaluation task. When selected this data table appears

Category

Name

Description

active

Sports &Activities

Organizations and services supporting an outdoor sporting lifestyle. Parent category: not to be usi 1

active.airsoft

Airsoft

A facility where airsoft, a military simulation sport where players particWe in mock combat with a

active.amateursportsteairis

Amateur Sports Team

Local sports teams, e g. baseball, football, basketball, competing at thij semi-professional level.

active, amusementparks

Amusement Park

Commercially operated parks featuring roller coasters, shooting galleries, merry-go-rounds, and n

active, amusementparks, ride

Amusement Park Ride

An attraction at an amusement park or carnivsil type event.

active.amusementparks.ride.rollercoasters

Roller Coaster

Roller coasters are a type of ride at amusement parks.

active.animalsports

Animal Sports

Sporting venues where animals are involved.

active.animalsports. bullring

Bull Ring

A bullring is an arena where bullfighting is performed. Bullrings are often associated with the Iberi;

active.animalsports. rodeoarena

Rodeo Arena

Professional and amateur rodeos are staged in large outdoor or indoor often air-conditioned aren;

.

2.6.2Category – Category Rating Rules
Rule 1 – Always choose the best fit category in the category list
Review the official website and social media pages
In cases of conflicting information, the information on the official website takes precedence

Rule 2 – Read reviews to help you determine the correct category

Read reviews from social media and crowdsourced user review websites
In cases of conflicting information, the information on the official website takes precedence

Rule 3 – When multiple categories equally describe the POI, use the business name to decide

If multiple categories equally describe the POI, refer to the name of the POI, with words that appear first in the name taking precedence (i.e. Pizza & Steak = Pizza)

Rule 4 – Do not rely on categories designated by Search Engine Results Pages (SERPs) or crowdsourced user review sites

SERPs and crowdsourced user review sites may assign categories to POIs, but these may not be accurate, follow the same rules or correspond to the category list used in this task.

 

.

 

.

2.7 Pin (POI Evaluation Guidelines, section 9. Pin Accuracy)

When rating Pin Accuracy, a judgement is made on whether the pin falls on the rooftop of a POI or feature in

question. Pin Accuracy rating is based on a consensus from multiple online resources.

Official venue materials

 
2.7 Pin continued…

Rating the Pin accurately can become a little more complex in situations where POIs share spaces with other POIs, for example in shopping malls, or larger, subdivided buildings.

Pin accuracy is rated on a principle of Best Available Evidence.

If street imagery or other strong evidence confirms POI’s specific location under a shared rooftop, only that location will be considered Perfect
Should no strong evidence be found for a POI’s location under a shared rooftop, then the entire rooftop is considered Perfect
When several rooftops share an address and there’s no strong evidence to confirm which rooftop houses the POI, all rooftops sharing the POI’s address will be considered Can’t Verify

HINT: Rate pin placement based on what you can actually see in the Rating Tool layers

2.7 Pin continued…

Another pin rating possibility is that of Approximate, guidelines sections 9.3. Single Rooftop POIs and section 9.4. Multiple Rooftop POIs

A pin is considered Approximate if it drops within the boundary of the property but not on the specific rooftop or section of rooftop housing the POI as confirmed by street and satellite imagery.

The following two examples look at two different scenarios where the pin rating is Approximate.

HINT: The resource https://danmarksadresser.dk/ is a good starting point for research.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Post