This document aims highlight trends that still remain to be a common issue across the analysts in your market.
This document was made in March 2024. Guideline sections / page numbers in this document refer to POI Evaluation Guideline March 2024. Please follow the latest guideline if there is any conflict between this document and the latest guideline if you have the later version of the guideline than March 2024.
You can find the latest guideline here.
https://geoworkerz.telusinternational.ai/mapping/StartWorking/Documents/POI%20Guidelines.pdf
The tasks/answers in this document reflect information when this document was made. It might not follow the latest real world’s situation anymore.
However, you should still be able to learn concepts how to rate POI tasks
POI Validity : No – Service Business out of a Home
Generally, a locksmith does not have a physical location where the user can visit, therefore, it should not be considered as POI and No – Service Business out of a Home would be justified for POI Validity and no further ratings are required.
Please see Guideline Section 3.1 POI Validity Rating Options.
Some analysts chose “Correct “ for Name Accuracy. However, according to https://rb.gy/2rjm4k, Name is missing branch name information 桜田東店. Therefore, Name Accuracy is Partially Correct.
Please see Japan Country Specific GL 4.2 Missing Store Location.
Address : Incorrect – Street Number
According to the official website, their address is 山形県山形市桜田東4丁目1-27.
Therefore, Address Accuracy is Incorrect – Street Number.
According to the official website, their phone number is +810236157311 thus, Phone is Incorrect.
The business has an official location-specific website.
https://www.gyomusuper.jp/shop/detail.php?sh_id=1027
Transit POI – Address : OK Without
Please remember, when transit POI doesn’t have an official address there are a few possible outcomes depending on the type of POI and the listing address.
For this case, the POI is Non-Conventionally Located POI and the listing address contains less specific address information than usual. Therefore, OK Without is justified.
Please see Guideline section 5.2. POIs Without an Official Address.
Also Correct is accepted for this case to follow Country Specific Guidelines 3. Required Address Components (POIs with no expected address)
Address : Incorrect
Most of wrong ratings for Address occurs due to lack of research or overlooking official resources.
Please give a closer look at address because the listing address on TryRating could miss something small.
The example of right misses 井出ノ口according to their website. https://www.milch-japan.co.jp/shops/
Therefore, Address accuracy would be Incorrect – Sub-Locality.
Please see Guideline section 5. Address Accuracy and Country Specific Guidelines 2. Address Components in Rating Interface.
Name should be 由布院ミルヒドーナツアンドカフェ店. You can confirm it with their website.
Their opening hours can be found in URL above. You can find their usual hours under 由布院ミルヒドーナツアンドカフェ店.
Please note, some business could list their hours outside of pages where their branches/shops’ information is found. Do not assume the business doesn’t list their hours when you don’t see it where it’s supposed to be.
Category : Incorrect
Some analysts chose “Correct“ or “Approximate – Category is too general“ for Category. The correct category is Incorrect and should be consumer sector ➞ financial service ➞ banking service ➞ atm.
Please do not forget to check Category for each business. You might find a better category than the listed one.
Please see Guidelines 8.1. Category Rating Options and 8.2.
Category Accuracy and Fit.
We can confirm Pin is not accurate on the map. Resources
https://bit.ly/3i97kZi , https://bit.ly/3ydwTOE
The listed pin location is 35.35139, 136.85525
The correct pin should fall at 35.351458, 136.855574
The current Pin falls a location where faces other side of the block which is further than where Half ’n’ Half rule can be applied. Therefore, Pin accuracy is Wrong. Please see Guidelines 9.8.1.
Hours: Incorrect
Some businesses especially restaurants have “Last order time“ “Last entry time” in Japan.
Hoshino Coffee
Komatsu-Shop
When the business has actual “Closing time”, we should consider that it is their closing time.
For this case, their website lists “Last entry time” (21:00) and “Closing time” (22:40) therefore, the listed hours on TryRating are wrong and analysts are expected to choose Incorrect and enter
the correct opening/closing time.
If the business does not list actual “Closing time” but “Last entry time” or “Last order time”, analysts are expected to choose
Incorrect and enter “other” in the correction field (For example 10:00 – other).
Please see Guideline section 10.7. Hours Corrections for more information
Case study – 1
POI Validity : Yes
Some analysts chose “ No – Not a POI “ for this POI. However, the guideline lists public restrooms as “ Yes “ for POI Validity.
Please see Guidelines 3.1. for more information regarding POI Validity Rating Options.
Phone, URL, Hours : OK without
There is a website of 上池袋公園
(https://www.city.toshima.lg.jp/340/shisetsu/koen/017.html),
but it is not for the public restroom. There is no Phone number and URL provided for the target POI therefore, Phone number and URL would be rated OK Without.
Also, Hours is OK without because this POI is always expected to be open. Please see Guidelines 10.1. for more information regarding Hours rating option.
Do not choose “No – Not a POI/No – Closed/Can’t Verify for POI Validity because 代々木店 is not listed in the store locater. If you research, you will find that this is a valid POI for the headquarter of Gap Inc.
Per GL. 1.1 POIs examples, company headquarters are listed as POI. Always doublecheck the POI validity with the street imagery.
it should be ギャップジャパン
Per GL. 7.1. URL Rating Options, the listed URL is for a sub-page that is neither the main page of the official website or a relevant location-specific page. Correct URL should be https://www.gapinc.com/ja-jp/about/company-profile
When the listed URLs are no longer used, do not conclude that the POI is no longer valid. The official websites can be temporarily under maintenance or possibly changed the URL. Research for a valid URL. Review GL 7.1. URL Rating Options, and rate Incorrect- The business has an official website, but the listed URL points to a different site or returns an error message (e.g. 404 error, domain hosting page, etc.).
Correct Category should be commercial sector→real estate→corporate campus→corporate headquarters. GAP is known as a company that sells clothes, but this particular POI is for the headquarter of GAP Inc. Always go through the category lists to make sure the given category is correct.
The result is for a headquarter, so this POI is not expected to have open hours like stores.
Comments are mandatory anytime there is information found that contradicts the POI listing. Here are a few specific items to note in the comments:
• List research URLs used to verify the POIs.
• Include any other findings and issues observed during the verification process.
• If the correct POI information is not apparent from the rating results, please also mention the correct POI data in the comment box. This is helpful when the results are analysed, and one needs to understand the cause of rating demotions (if any).
If you see a message “Required data is missing Release this task with Technical Issue as a reason”, please report to us. An updated version of the “How to use TryRating document” is now available on the AI Community portal (Task > Task Releasing > Other Reasons).
https://geoworkerz.telusinternational.ai/mapping/Timesheet/Pages/TaskReleasing.aspx
Please follow the instruction on section 12. [Troubleshooting – Browser Developer Tools]. We will escalate the issue to the relevant team once we receive the screenshot from you.